Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy by John le Carré (1974)


‘…Mr George Smiley was not naturally equipped for hurrying in the rain, least of all at dead of night…
Small, podgy and at best middle-aged, he was by appearance one of London’s meek who do not inherit the earth.’

Control, the commander of the Circus (the highest level of British Intelligence) is eased out of his position and dies not long afterwards. His second in command, George Smiley, is later forced out into retirement after a series of operational disasters and the Circus is restructured.

‘After a lifetime of living by his wits and his considerable memory, he had given himself full-time to the profession of forgetting.’

But Peter Guillam, a former colleague whose role in the Circus has been curtailed since the restructure, has evidence that Circus has been infiltrated by a mole over a period of decades. He recruits Smiley to ‘spy on the spies.’
As Smiley works to uncover this betrayal in the upper echelons of the organisation, he also faces a  betrayal in his personal life.

The Spy Who Came in From the Cold was the first Cold War novel by John le Carré that I’d read (see my review in this post).
* Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy, was the second. The two books have similarities and share one or two characters but they both may be read as stand alone titles.
Betrayal is a dominant theme in both books, but it is more fully explored in the second.
Le Carré writes superbly and his plots are complex. Both novels are psychological thrillers and somewhat dark, which is not surprising for books about espionage.

Normally I’m only attracted to softer vintage espionage – authors such as John Buchan and Helen MacInnes – but le Carré sucked me in with his masterful exploration of character. He made me care about some of these characters. People such as Smiley and Bill Roach, the new boy at school who was considered dull, if not actually deficient, and blamed himself for the break-up of his parent’s marriage; Jim Prideaux, the enigmatic hunchbacked teacher who arrived at the school as a temporary replacement:

‘Bill had a feeling he could not describe that Jim lived so precariously on the world’s surface that he might at any time fall into a void; for he feared that Jim was like himself, without a natural gravity to hold him on.’

And Peter Guillam, who in a moment feels not only betrayed but orphaned by the man who inspired him most: 

‘His butchered agents in Morocco, his exile to Brixton, the daily frustration of his efforts as daily he grew older and youth slipped through his fingers; the drabness that was closing round him; the truncation of his power to love, enjoy and laugh; the constant erosion of the plain, heroic standards he wished to live by…
His suspicions, his resentments for so long turned outwards on the real world – on his women, his attempted loves – now swung upon the Circus and the failed magic which had formed his faith.’

This is an excellent, gritty read but I sometimes felt out of my depth with the complexity of the plot, although I found with both of le Carré’s books that once I have the whole picture at the end of the book it helps me untangle some of the threads and I can then skip back to sections where I got a little lost and work things out.

* When a movie was made of the book in 2011, the commas were removed for the film title.


16 thoughts on “Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy by John le Carré (1974)

  1. i've thought that his Smiley books were his best… i've read a couple of his later books but didn't like them because of their endings, which seemed to end disastrously for the protagonists… maybe too dark for my taste, i guess…


  2. I have been meaning to read The Spy who Came In From the Cold for a long time. I think that once I begin the series I might keep going. My understanding was that La Carré was still adding to this series as of 2017.


  3. Oh, now you've inspired me to read a more modern book. I own one LeCarre but I can't remember which one. I think it's The Russia House but I can't be sure. Going to look now. Thanks for the excellent review!


  4. Hi Brian, I decided to read The Spy who Came In From the Cold after someone (??) mentioned how much they enjoyed it & because it's one of those titles that stays in your mind once you've heard it.


  5. Hi Cleo, I've decided to read a few more modern books this year, just to stretch my reading a little, as well as some non-fiction, which I've neglected in recent years in favour of literature classics. I'll still be fitting in the old books, though!


  6. You know, John LeCarre just depresses me. I read The Spy Who Came in From the Cold. It was good and kept me going, but what a yucky ending. I'm glad I read your review, because I'm sure I've enjoyed it more than the actual book.


  7. I really need to re-read these books. I read the Karla Trilogy and then a handful of others way back in the 1990s and was hooked. But now I remember very little (actually NOTHING) about the plots. What I remember most was how much bureaucracy and politics was involved in the spying – not exactly James Bond-type action. I agree with you that le Carre is a fantastic writer of characters.


  8. This book was mentioned in H is for Hawk when I read it recently and that's the only reason I started it. It tends not to be a genre I have the brain for – too many subtleties but come to think of it, so does Dickens & I like reading his books.


  9. Pingback: The Classics Club: A New List | journey & destination

  10. Pingback: A Prince and a Spy by Rory Clements | journey & destination

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s